Semi-rigid card holders vs toploaders
For grading and for storage, put it in a TopRipz.
A semi-rigid card holder and a toploader do different jobs. A toploader is a hard case for storage and shipping. A semi-rigid holder, such as a Card Saver, is thinner, and the card slides out. For grading and for storage, put it in a TopRipz.
Regular semi-rigid sleeves are either too tight or too flimsy. Tight ones drag on the card when you pull it out, and flimsy ones do not protect it. A TopRipz has a rigid back and a soft/flexible front. Silk finish for smooth handling, so the card goes in easily and stays in a secure hold. A TopRipz fits cards up to 50pt.
Cards release effortlessly with the patent-pending RipTag, or can be removed like a standard loader. The RipTag Grading Strip is optional, patent-pending, and one-time use. One pull and the card is out, then the grader recycles the strip, with no prying and no risk of damage from handling.
Compare the holders
| Feature | TopRipz | Toploader | Semi-rigid |
|---|---|---|---|
| Back and front | TopRipzRigid back, soft/flexible front | ToploaderRigid shell on all sides | Semi-rigidThin, flexible holder |
| Getting the card out | TopRipzOne pull with the patent-pending RipTag, or like a standard loader | ToploaderSlide the penny sleeve out. Corners can catch. | Semi-rigidSlide the card out. Tight holders drag. |
| Card thickness | TopRipzFits cards up to 50pt | ToploaderDepends on the brand | Semi-rigidDepends on the brand |
| Surface | TopRipzSilk finish for smooth handling | ToploaderHard plastic | Semi-rigidPlain semi-rigid plastic |
| Typical use | TopRipzStorage, shipping, and CGC grading prep | ToploaderStorage and shipping | Semi-rigidGrading submissions and short-term holding |
Which one to use
Storage
A toploader is a hard case collectors use for storage. For a card you are keeping, put it in a TopRipz. The rigid back resists a bend, and the soft/flexible front stays clear. Shop a TopRipz or browse the shop.
CGC grading
For the card you submit, put it in a TopRipz. CGC's packaging instructions call for a sleeve sturdy enough to remove the card safely. That page does not describe a hard toploader as the submission sleeve. The steps are on how to prepare and submit cards for CGC grading.
The grading kit ships 10 TopRipz in a secure shipper with a microfiber cloth, a foam insert, a plate, and a prepaid return label.
Taking the card out
How to remove a card covers a TopRipz, a card saver, and a toploader. More questions are on the FAQ.
FAQ
What is the difference between a card saver and a toploader?
A Card Saver is a semi-rigid holder. It flexes, and the card slides out. A toploader is a rigid case for storage. The card can be harder to slide out of a toploader.
Which holder should I use for grading?
Put it in a TopRipz. It has a rigid back and a soft/flexible front, and it fits cards up to 50pt. CGC's packaging page asks for a sleeve sturdy enough to remove the card safely. It does not describe a hard toploader as that sleeve.
Can I store a card in a semi-rigid holder?
Put it in a TopRipz for storage and shipping. A rigid back keeps the card flatter than a thin semi-rigid that can bow. A toploader is the hard case many collectors use for storage.
What is different about a TopRipz?
A TopRipz has a rigid back and a soft/flexible front. Silk finish for smooth handling, so the card goes in easily and stays in a secure hold. Cards release effortlessly with the patent-pending RipTag, or can be removed like a standard loader. The RipTag Grading Strip is optional, patent-pending, and one-time use. One pull and the card is out, then the grader recycles the strip, with no prying and no risk of damage from handling. A TopRipz fits cards up to 50pt.